Pascua (Easter), Latinos, and Clashing Identities

This is the first time in 22 years that I don’t go to mass on Domingo de Pascua (easter). Every year, since I can remember, Semana Santa was filled with Misas (mass), resos, comida, and a series of other spanish spoken things. My father joked that on Domingo de Pascuas, it would be packed, because it would be the one day everyone would go to Misa. He was right. Growing up, my family would go to church every Domingo. Most weeks it would be at 75% capacity. But today, it would be at 200%, and with almost everyone rocking their best (new) attire. From freshly pressed suits, to too tight dresses. And the unhappy faces of kids (including me) wanting to get out of the not so good looking button up shirt Abuela bought us. 

But this year I find myself in Liverpool. I live next to the Catholic Cathedral, literally, and going to Easter mass (or any of the scheduled ceremonies) would have been effortless. But I didn’t go.

For a while now, I have considered myself to no longer accept or embrace the Abrahamic faith of Christianity as my own. I am not Catholic. I do not believe in the Abrahamic God, or the divinity of Jesus, though I think he was a seriously progressive and revolutionary guy (for his time), even if he didn’t actually exist. But there is something that came to mind today. If I were in New York, I would have gone to Misa.

I can’t identify with being a Catholic, but there are certain practices growing up that I knew to be more Latino than Catholic. Misa was not only to hear “la palabra”, but to gather as a community, to see friends, family, to gossip, to cry, to laugh, to catch up. And interestingly enough, it meant so much more that it was all in spanish.

I remember my Padre and Abuela telling me stories about Semana Santa from back home, how during the week all you would do is pray, and on Sabado de Gloria, la chancla would come out in full force (from having taken a break all of Semana Santa). My Abuela would make Torejas, something I miss so much right now. During the whole week, you would eat Casamiento, and every creative non-meat dish possible (hard for Argentines). We would pray, but we would also get together for the sake of it, all week. I would hang with friends from Misa, cousins, everyone. Even on Sunday, the people who you would never see re-entered your life, sometimes only for moments, but mostly for comida at someones house, the diner, or at a party. Growing up, Pascua meant something more than a man named Jesus experiencing the story of “la pasion”.

But as I grew up, I confronted the contradiction of the religion I was born into. And so, I abandoned the belief system and chose another path. Today, I would identify as something else, and maybe consider myself to be “searching”. Even so, there is something I cannot divorce myself from, and that is my Latino roots.

Culturally speaking, I might as well be Catholic. I would still go to “La Misa de Gallo” (I did actually, with two fellow Marshalls in Amsterdam this past Christmas) because its how I was brought up and feels part of my Latino identity. Instead of waiting for “Papa Noel” till morning to open presents (which I would tease my non-Latino friends about) we would open them after we got back from Misa at midnight, sometimes later because we would make a stop at someones house for more food. As I grew older, I would joke with friends that while no one would go to the ceremony at La Iglesia for a baptism or Quince blessing, damn well everyone would be at the party. Comuniones were a huge deal too. Not only had the kids passed their tests and learned their “resos”, but they now got to parade through the Iglesia halls in all white mini sized suits and dresses, holding elaborate hand decorated candles, holy books from a botanica, and rosarios, sometimes made out of gold and silver, as gifts from their Padrinos. That day, like Pascua, Misa would be at 200% capacity, everyone with their digital cameras, some with the dying breed of disposables, looking like the paparazzi, trying to capture their kid eating “la ostia” or making that face when they taste wine for the first time. And of course, all the parties that followed.

Many of these religious ceremonies, rituals, and events are interlinked with culture. As a Latino, part of my identity was created and challenged in the halls of La Iglesia. In those halls, everything happened. From playing outside and scaling the Monastery walls as kids, to growing up and talking about dating and school. But what also happened was that we learned about our past, nuestros paises, and who we were, in Spanish with English subtitles. However, religion was never at the forefront of these experiences.

So what? Many who know me know that the clashes I have with religion are fundamental to my understanding of oppression. For me, Catholicism is the religion of the colonizer, as it was the Spanish Crown that forced it upon my ancestors. There are other things I disagree with, such as how homophobic religious dogma is, patriarchal, and so on. But I also understand that for my community, and yes, I am still part of that community, religion is an intrinsic part of their identity.

The personal struggle is twofold. I don’t want to be a hypocrite and be part of an institution I fundamentally disagree with. However, I also want to maintain my roots intact, and part of those roots are found in the halls of that Catholic monastery in Suffern, especially since so many I love consider that place their spiritual and personal home.

Right now, I am trying to find answers to these questions. Maybe in these two years away, I’ll find it.


4 thoughts on “Pascua (Easter), Latinos, and Clashing Identities”

  1. This is a great post Nico! I can relate to your desire to remain true to yourself while remaining steeped in your heritage. The struggle is real.

  2. It is very likely that your ancestors were the colonizers as well as the colonized.

    What is your reasoning for rejecting the former and accepting the latter?

    As people of the Americas (Americans), I don’t see the benefit in rejecting our Spanish heritage and culture anymore than that of our Amerind, African, or other ancestors.

    This is rejection is common in academia, and I suspect that for many, it is a means of reinforcing the idea that Americans of predominantly anglo/germanic stock, (AKA white people), are a monolithic “other” and the colonizers, and that all people of predominantly iberophone, Amerind, and African heritage (AKA latino, brown, black) are themselves a homogenous group, the colonized.
    This is not true, especially in the case of “latinos”, nor I think useful. Not assuming this is your reasoning of course.

    Also, you mention feeling a fondness for the Spanish language as spoken at your church. By the criteria with which you reject Catholicism, it would seem you should also reject the Spanish language altogether.

    1. First point: Indeed, my ancestors are also likely to be the colonizers, or the beneficiaries of. However, within the American imagination, to which is embodied by the super imposed narrative constructed by the state politic and its history, I cannot and am not (through several medium such as the law) associated with them. My exclusivity is that of a person of color, or other, and so, partially, I am forced to contend with that identity. Within the historical re-tracing of the Spanish Empire, you are correct, but that identity is almost always entirely eradicated, both on a global, continental, and local level. Within the script, I cannot be as the colonizers are/were (which within the politically correct discourse, is a word non-existent) because of the color of my skin. I am not a complex human being, rather, I am what is imposed, Latino, which is synonymous with other (and other things). This, of course, is not true. Even so, rather than rejecting the imposition all together, I reclaim it, and deconstruct that lived reality, because it is inevitably part of who I am, both in the intimate and the public collective.

      Which leads to the second point. Growing up, there is then a existential wondering. I am treated as such, and as one develops, there is typically a natural inclination to react as such. I am brown, the imagination dictates that my enemy is white. There is rage, and the imagination works perhaps as intended. The White Supremacy script reinforces a divide. As time progresses, I at least, see the process of thought is extremely problematic and untrue, if it is invoked in the singular. The imagination includes the treatment of the Irish, Italian, German, etc. However, history is blurred, because of the evolving manifestation of power, and power either has a desire to expand or maintain its current political and social infrastructure.

      Groups, including “white people”, are not monolithic, but system in which we exist in make them so. Power dynamics play out in particular ways, tied to history. Also, the rejection was not my reasoning, rather, more of a reflection than critique.

      Spanish has a less problematic internal conflict, though similar. Spanish was also forced upon the indigenous people of the continent and those who were brought over, as english was in the northern reaches. But language and religion are very different. My fundamental disagreements with religion are not the same, or even comparable, to language. Spanish is what we speak, as is english. From my vantage point, it would seem impractical to reject it, and pointless, as language is fundamental to communicate with others. Religion on the other hand, I can reject, as it is a set of beliefs, and not essential to my own survival (though that is a matter of opinion, I suppose).

      Also. I reject religion not on only because of how it was used to colonize and control the psyche (and truly, that has much less to do with it), but because I disagree with it and believe it oft times does much more harm that good. That statement is very loaded, and my thoughts on religion are far more complex than that one sentence. That discussion is for another time.

      Thanks for the commentary – it seems a conversation between us is long overdue, and one that does not happen over the interwebs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s